Research explained: randomized controlled crossover trial

An ultra-processed meal raised insulin more than a nutritionally matched meal in a randomized crossover trial

In 57 healthy-weight adults, a meal of ultra-processed foods led to a larger insulin response and less carbohydrate burning than a less processed meal with the same nutrients, and brain scans showed different responses to food cues.

A meal made of ultra-processed foods produced a bigger insulin response and more energy use, but less carbohydrate burning, than a less processed meal with matching nutrients, according to a randomized crossover trial of 57 healthy-weight adults published in Nature Metabolism on October 5, 2026. Brain scans also showed that the two meals were linked to different responses to food pictures. The trial made headlines in many outlets because it suggests processing may matter beyond calories and macronutrients.

What the researchers did

A team at the Fralin Biomedical Research Institute at Virginia Tech gave each participant two meals on separate occasions, in random order. One was built from ultra-processed foods and the other from foods that were not ultra-processed, and the two were matched on nutrition. After eating, the researchers measured insulin, energy expenditure and how much carbohydrate the body was burning. They also used brain imaging while participants looked at food cues.

The ultra-processed meal led to higher insulin and energy responses, with lower carbohydrate oxidation. The size of the difference in peak carbohydrate burning between the two meals was linked to activity in the striatum, a brain area involved in reward and motivation. People rated the value of foods the same after both meals, but brain activity related to those ratings went in opposite directions: positive after the less processed meal and negative after the ultra-processed one.

How strong is the evidence?

A randomized crossover design is a strong way to compare two meals, because each person acts as their own control. The study is still small, it tested single meals in healthy-weight adults, and it measured short-term responses. It cannot show whether these effects add up to weight gain or disease over months or years. The authors declare no competing interests.

What it means for you

This trial adds to the case that how a food is made may matter, not just its nutrition label. You do not need to avoid every packaged food, but building more meals around minimally processed staples such as oats or an apple, and having snacks like potato chips less often, is a practical step. You can compare breads, including white bread, on our pages, or browse grains.

Sources

  1. Hutelin Z, Ahrens M, Baugh ME, Nartey E, Herald DL 3rd, Hanlon AL, DiFeliceantonio AG. Metabolic and neural responses to ultraprocessed foods: a randomized, controlled, crossover study. Nat Metab. 2026 Oct;8(10):2152-2164. doi:10.1038/s42255-026-01619-4. PMID 42834140.