Butter vs mayonnaise: which is healthier?

Mayonnaise is more nutrient-dense, scoring 9/100 against 4/100 for butter. Both can be part of a healthy diet; the table below shows where each one is stronger. Source: USDA FoodData Central.

Butter

4/100Low nutrient density

717 kcal per 100 g. 1 tbsp: 14 g

Mayonnaise

9/100Low nutrient density

680 kcal per 100 g. 1 tbsp: 14 g

Higher score

Which to pick for your goal

  • Fewer caloriesAbout even717 vs 680 kcal per 100 g
  • More proteinAbout even0.8 vs 1 g per 100 g
  • More fiberAbout even0 vs 0 g per 100 g
  • Less sugarButter<0.1 vs 0.6 g per 100 g
  • More potassiumButter24 vs 20 mg per 100 g
  • Less saturated fatMayonnaise50 vs 12 g per 100 g

Nutrition side by side

Per 100 g and per typical portion. Bold marks the better value for each row.
NutrientButter, 100 gMayonnaise, 100 gButter, 14 gMayonnaise, 14 g
Calories717 kcal680 kcal102 kcal95 kcal
Protein0.8 g1 g0.1 g0.1 g
Carbohydrates<0.1 g0.6 g<0.1 g<0.1 g
Sugars<0.1 g0.6 g<0.1 g<0.1 g
Fiber0 g0 g0 g0 g
Fat81 g75 g12 g10 g
Saturated fat50 g12 g7.2 g1.6 g
Vitamin C0 mg0 mg0 mg0 mg
Vitamin A684 µg16 µg97 µg2.2 µg
Potassium24 mg20 mg3.4 mg2.8 mg
Iron<0.1 mg0.2 mg<0.1 mg<0.1 mg
Calcium24 mg8 mg3.4 mg1.1 mg
Magnesium2 mg1 mg0.3 mg0.1 mg
Sodium11 mg635 mg1.6 mg89 mg

Last updated . Scores use the HowHealthyIs Score method.

All about butter All about mayonnaise Open in compare tool