Research explained: randomized controlled trial
Moderate red meat and plant-based meat alternatives had similar effects on heart and metabolic markers in a 10-week trial
In a randomized trial of healthy adults in New Zealand, a flexitarian diet with moderate pasture-raised red meat and a vegetarian diet with plant-based meat alternatives showed no difference in cardiometabolic biomarkers, while one omega-3 fat dipped temporarily in the vegetarian group.
Healthy adults who ate moderate amounts of pasture-raised red meat as part of a healthy diet for 10 weeks showed no difference in cardiometabolic biomarkers compared with adults on a vegetarian diet built around plant-based meat alternatives, according to a randomized trial published in the American Journal of Clinical Nutrition. The one clear difference was in docosapentaenoic acid (DPA), an omega-3 fat in the blood: it fell in the vegetarian group over the first 5 weeks (estimate -6.47 μmol/L, 95% CI -10.39 to -2.56) and then recovered by week 10.
What the researchers did
A team from the University of Auckland and Massey University in New Zealand assigned healthy adults to one of two healthy eating patterns in their normal daily lives. The flexitarian group included pasture-raised red meat, reaching 3.3 serves a week by week 10. The vegetarian group used plant-based meat alternatives instead. The researchers measured blood fatty acids, cardiometabolic biomarkers and 259 lipid species at the start, at 5 weeks and at 10 weeks, and accounted for people from the same household. Seventy-eight participants completed the study.
How strong is the evidence?
This was a randomized dietary trial, registered as NCT04869163, but it was small and short, and it included only healthy adults. Because many blood fats were tested, the authors corrected for multiple comparisons; DPA and a single lipid species, PE-O 39:6, remained significant, both staying stable with red meat and declining on the vegetarian diet. The trial was not designed to show effects on heart disease itself. Two authors reported financial support from New Zealand’s National Science Challenge High Value Nutrition, the Ministry of Business, Innovation and Employment, and the Meat Industry Association; the other authors reported no conflicts of interest.
What it means for you
Within an overall healthy diet, a few servings a week of red meat such as ground beef did not worsen the heart and metabolic markers measured here, and neither did a vegetarian pattern. If you eat mostly plants, foods like tofu and lentils are solid protein sources, and it is worth thinking about where your omega-3 fats come from. Compare more options in meat and fish and legumes.