Italian vs Japanese Dinner: Calories and Nutrients

Twelve Italian and nine Japanese dishes compared on score, calories, protein, fiber, saturated fat and sodium, plus five typical dinners side by side.

Neither cuisine wins outright. In our database, Japanese dishes are lower in calories and much lower in saturated fat, while Italian dishes bring more fiber and less sodium. The 12 Italian dishes average 187 kcal and 4.5 g of saturated fat per 100 g; the 9 Japanese dishes average 149 kcal and 1.2 g. Japanese dishes carry more salt, though: 362 mg of sodium per 100 g against 264 mg. The healthiest single dishes are minestrone (score 68) on the Italian side and miso soup (47) on the Japanese side. A dinner of miso soup and chicken teriyaki comes to 700 kcal with 48 g of protein, while tonkotsu ramen with gyoza passes the full day’s Daily Value for both sodium and saturated fat.

How do the two cuisines compare overall?

Averages per 100 g across every dish of each cuisine in our database. The score is the HowHealthyIs Score out of 100, which rates nutrient density per calorie.

Per 100 g, average Italian (12 dishes) Japanese (9 dishes)
Score 29 25
Calories 187 kcal 149 kcal
Protein 6.4 g 8.1 g
Fiber 1.2 g 0.6 g
Saturated fat 4.5 g 1.2 g
Sodium 264 mg 362 mg

The pattern follows the ingredients. Italian cooking leans on cheese, cream, butter and olive oil, which lift calories and saturated fat, and on vegetables, beans and pasta, which bring fiber. Japanese cooking leans on rice, fish, chicken and soy-based seasonings such as soy sauce and miso, which keep fat low and push sodium up. Two Italian desserts, tiramisu and panna cotta, also pull the Italian averages toward more saturated fat.

Which Italian dishes are healthiest?

Per portion, sorted by score. Portions are the first portion listed on each dish page.

Dish Score Portion kcal Protein Fiber Sat. fat Sodium
Minestrone 68 1 bowl, 350 g 182 7 g 5.1 g 1.2 g 720 mg
Penne arrabbiata 41 1 plate, 410 g 529 17 g 7.3 g 1.8 g 1,161 mg
Eggplant parmigiana 38 280 g 507 18 g 7.5 g 11.6 g 987 mg
Spaghetti bolognese 37 1 plate, 430 g 662 35 g 5.6 g 8.2 g 1,061 mg
Lasagna 34 1 piece, 300 g 501 25 g 3.5 g 11.3 g 764 mg
Caprese salad 33 1 starter, 170 g 267 15 g 1.3 g 9.6 g 494 mg
Margherita pizza 23 half a pizza, 285 g 752 28 g 4.8 g 10.3 g 1,373 mg
Pesto pasta 23 1 plate, 300 g 714 20 g 3.8 g 6.5 g 793 mg
Spaghetti carbonara 20 1 plate, 330 g 706 33 g 3.4 g 11.6 g 1,090 mg
Mushroom risotto 15 1 plate, 400 g 536 14 g 1.2 g 8.2 g 1,270 mg

Tomato-based dishes lead. Penne arrabbiata, with its tomato and chili sauce, has the most fiber per plate and the least saturated fat of any Italian main. Cheese-heavy dishes such as lasagna, eggplant parmigiana and carbonara each carry more than half of the 20 g Daily Value for saturated fat in one portion. Tiramisu adds 14.5 g of saturated fat per square and panna cotta 19.3 g per ramekin, so dessert can double the saturated fat of the evening.

Which Japanese dishes are healthiest?

Dish Score Portion kcal Protein Fiber Sat. fat Sodium
Miso soup 47 1 bowl, 240 g 96 10 g 1.1 g 0.8 g 928 mg
Chicken katsu curry 37 1 plate, 550 g 776 38 g 5.6 g 5.8 g 968 mg
Chicken yakitori 35 2 skewers, 80 g 121 15 g 0.6 g 0.8 g 542 mg
Chicken teriyaki 22 1 plate with rice, 380 g 604 38 g 0.5 g 2.2 g 1,011 mg
Pork gyoza 22 6 gyoza, 140 g 336 14 g 1.7 g 4.5 g 526 mg
Salmon nigiri 19 2 pieces, 70 g 122 6 g 0.1 g 0.8 g 301 mg
California roll 16 8 pieces, 220 g 330 7 g 2.5 g 1.7 g 714 mg
Salmon onigiri 16 1 onigiri, 135 g 212 8 g 0 g 0.6 g 409 mg
Tonkotsu ramen 12 1 bowl, 830 g 1,046 38 g 3.8 g 20.2 g 2,625 mg

Most Japanese dishes are lean, and several are high in protein for their calories: two yakitori skewers give 15 g of protein for 121 kcal. Fiber is where Japanese food falls short, because white rice and fish bring very little. Sodium is the main thing to watch. A bowl of miso soup holds 928 mg, about 40% of the 2,300 mg Daily Value, and a bowl of tonkotsu ramen holds 2,625 mg, more than the whole day’s Daily Value, along with 20.2 g of saturated fat.

What does a typical dinner look like?

Six common restaurant dinners, added up from the dish portions above.

Dinner kcal Protein Fiber Sat. fat Sodium
Minestrone + penne arrabbiata 711 24 g 12.4 g 3.0 g 1,881 mg
Minestrone + spaghetti bolognese 844 42 g 10.7 g 9.4 g 1,781 mg
Caprese salad + half a margherita pizza 1,019 43 g 6.1 g 19.9 g 1,867 mg
Miso soup + chicken teriyaki 700 48 g 1.6 g 3.0 g 1,939 mg
California roll + 4 salmon nigiri + miso soup 670 29 g 3.8 g 4.1 g 2,244 mg
Tonkotsu ramen + 6 gyoza 1,382 52 g 5.5 g 24.7 g 3,151 mg

Every one of these dinners passes 1,700 mg of sodium, so restaurant dinners in either cuisine use up most of the day’s salt. Beyond that, the best Italian dinner here wins on fiber and the best Japanese dinner wins on protein per calorie. The pizza dinner comes within 0.1 g of the full Daily Value for saturated fat, and the ramen dinner passes it.

How do you order a healthier dinner in each cuisine?

Italian:

  • Start with minestrone or another vegetable soup.
  • Choose tomato-based sauces over cream, butter or a lot of cheese.
  • Share the dessert.

Japanese:

  • Pick grilled dishes such as yakitori and fish.
  • Add a side of vegetables or edamame for the fiber that rice lacks.
  • Go light on soy sauce.
  • Treat ramen broth as something to taste rather than finish.

For more side-by-side numbers, browse the Italian and Japanese cuisine pages or compare any two dishes with our compare tool.

General nutrition information, not medical advice.

Sources

  1. U.S. Department of Agriculture, Agricultural Research Service. FoodData Central, SR Legacy. fdc.nal.usda.gov
  2. U.S. Food and Drug Administration. Daily Value on the Nutrition and Supplement Facts Labels (21 CFR 101.9). fda.gov